Triage PR Review Comments

Fetch all review comments on the current PR, verify each finding against real code, fix valid issues, and push.

Phase 1: Gather Comments

1. Determine the PR number:

   • Use $ARGUMENTS if provided
   • Otherwise: gh pr view --json number --jq .number

2. Fetch ALL comments (reviewers post in multiple places):

   Copy

   gh api --paginate repos/{owner}/{repo}/pulls/{pr}/reviews
   gh api --paginate repos/{owner}/{repo}/pulls/{pr}/comments
   gh api --paginate repos/{owner}/{repo}/issues/{pr}/comments
   

3. Extract unique findings — deduplicate across Copilot, Greptile, and human reviewers. Group by file and line.

Phase 2: Verify Each Finding

For EVERY finding, verify against real code before accepting or rejecting:

1. Read the actual code at the referenced file:line
2. Check if the issue still exists — it may already be fixed in a later commit
3. Verify correctness using:
   • Code analysis (read surrounding context, trace call paths)
   • Run btca resources to see what's available, then btca ask -r <resource> -q "..." for library/framework questions
   • Web search for API behavior, language semantics, or CVEs
4. Classify each finding:
   • Valid — real bug, real gap, or real improvement needed
   • False positive — reviewer misread the code, outdated reference, or style preference

Phase 3: Fix & Ship

1. Fix all Valid findings
2. Run the project's lint/test commands (check CLAUDE.md for exact commands)
   • If lint/tests fail, fix the failures before committing
   • If a failure cannot be fixed automatically, skip that fix and report it as Valid (unfixed) in the Phase 4 table
3. git add only changed files, git commit with message:
   Copy

   fix: Address PR review feedback
   
   - <one-line summary per fix>
   

4. Push: gt submit (or git push if not using Graphite)

Phase 4: Report

Present a final summary table of ALL findings with verdicts:

Notes

• Never dismiss a finding without reading the actual code first
• If unsure, err toward "Valid" — it's cheaper to fix than to miss a bug
• For library/API questions, always use btca or web search — don't guess